Immediate Competitive Impact Unlikely from French Spectrum Auction
Published on: 26th Nov 2015
Note -- this news article is more than a year old.
Fitch Ratings says the outcome of the 700 MHz mobile spectrum auction in France concluded last Tuesday is unlikely to have an immediate impact on the competitive dynamics in the market.
Over the medium-to long-term, operators with higher amounts of spectrum below 1GHz could gain a network cost and flexibility advantage as capacity requirements for LTE data grow. In the near-term Fitch expects existing competitive trends to persist as challenger Iliad continues to gain scale in mobile and strengthen its quad-play proposition.
The auction leaves Orange with a leading position of 31% of sub-1GHz spectrum, followed by Bouygues Telecom and Numericable-SFR (28% each) and Iliad (13%).
Orange's stronger spectrum holding will provide the company with greater flexibility in deploying its network and meeting capacity demand for growth. At end-2014 Orange's and Bouygues' networks covered just above 70% of the French population, ahead of Numericable-SFR's and Iliad's that only reached 53% and 33% respectively.
The auction saw Orange and Iliad secure two blocks of 5 MHz duplex each, while Bouygues Telecom and Numericable-SFR secured one block each. The total cost of the spectrum of EUR2.8bn is slightly above the reserve price of EUR2.5bn.
The auction was of particular importance to Iliad due to its lack of holding in the 800MHz band and 2x5MHz holding in the 900MHz band. Spectrum holdings in the lower bands are essential to achieving cost efficiency and in building geographic coverage. By securing two blocks of 700 MHz spectrum, Iliad has reduced its dependence on its 900MHz holding.
While competitive pressures are here to stay, Orange's substantial network investments secure the incumbent's operational prospects in the medium term, with a clear network advantage versus its competitors. The company's allocated 700 MHz spectrum will cost it EUR932m which is broadly in line with our expectation and has no material impact on our leverage assumptions for the company. Fitch revised Orange's Outlook from Negative to Stable in June 2015 as the company improved operational trends and cash flow generation.