UK's 4G Spectrum Auction May Not Have Been Economically Efficient
Published on: 12th Mar 2014
By: Ian Mansfield
A review of the UK's 4G spectrum auction last year has found that while the regulator achieved its aim of preserving competition in the market it may not have been an economically efficient auction.
A report from the government's National Audit Office said that the uncertainty is because it is not yet possible to assess whether those who were allocated spectrum during the auction are able to make the most effective use of it.
The auction raised £2.4 billion and Ofcom estimates it will provide benefits for consumers estimated at £20 billion.
The four existing national operators (EE, Three, O2 and Vodafone) all won spectrum through the auction process, and they now hold sufficient spectrum to ensure their medium-term viability, as assessed by Ofcom.
A new entrant, BT Niche, was also allocated a substantial holding of the spectrum.
Since the auction took place, all four of the existing mobile network operators have started to roll out 4G services. EE was allowed to offer 4G services from October 2012 using its existing holdings of spectrum.
According to the NAO report, whether or not the auction succeeded in allocating spectrum to those who can make best use of it will start to become apparent only as the spectrum is brought into use by the winning bidders.
Ofcom has statutory obligations to citizens and consumers and had no objective to achieve any particular level of proceeds.
Ofcom found that without intervention in the auction the smallest operator (Three) or a new entrant might not acquire the spectrum it needed to be an effective constraint on its rivals. It, therefore, reserved part of the spectrum for such an operator. Three successfully acquired this reserved spectrum through the auction. The Smith Institute calculated that the proceeds were £159 million lower than they would have been had the radio spectrum won by Three not been reserved for it or new entrants to the market.
However, the NAO compared the level of proceeds achieved, £2.4 billion, with the amounts obtained in other European 4G auctions and found that proceeds were within the range achieved in those other European auctions.