European Regulators Approve Microsoft-Nokia Deal
Published on: 4th Dec 2013
By: Ian Mansfield
The European Commission has cleared Microsoft's planned purchase of Nokia's mobile phone division after concluding that the deal would not raise any competition concerns.
The Commission concluded in particular that there are only modest overlaps between the parties' activities and the links between Microsoft's mobile operating systems, mobile applications and enterprise mail server software with Nokia's smart mobile devices are unlikely to lead to competitors being shut out from the market.
The Commission also said that several strong rivals, such as Samsung and Apple will continue to compete with the merged entity.
The Commission also investigated a number the vertical relationships between the merged entity's activities in the downstream market for smart mobile devices and Microsoft's upstream activities in mobile operating systems (OS), mobile applications (apps) and enterprise mail server software and related communication protocols.
The Commission concluded that Microsoft is unlikely to restrict the supply of its Windows OSs for smart mobile devices to third party device manufacturers after the transaction. Indeed it noted that Microsoft's share in the mobile OS market is limited. Moreover, to better compete with the leading Android and Apple OS platforms, Microsoft likely needs to continue relying on third party device suppliers to broaden consumer adoption and attract mobile app developers.
Microsoft is also unlikely to restrict the supply of its mobile apps, such as its Office suite apps and its communication app Skype, to competing providers of smart mobile devices. Since Office apps are currently not available on tablets running third party OSs, a potential supply restriction would be limited to other tablet suppliers using Microsoft's Windows OSs. However, this strategy would hamper Microsoft's interest to attract more app developers and ultimately users to its OSs for smart mobile devices. For smartphones, the share of Office apps is minimal and there are many popular competing apps. Similarly, with regard to Skype, other popular apps continue to be available. Moreover, given the low market share of Windows in mobile OSs, limiting interoperability with third-party mobile OSs would ultimately weaken Skype's competitive offering.
Microsoft would not have the ability to restrict the interoperability of competing smart mobile devices with Exchange Server, Microsoft's enterprise mail server software, because of the contractual terms of their current licenses to Microsoft patents covering the communication protocol that manages synchronisation of email, calendar and contacts between smart mobile devices and Microsoft Exchange. Moreover, given the limited portion of the market which could be foreclosed and the merged entity's very small market position in the smart mobile device market, such a conduct would in any event not produce anti-competitive effects.
The Commission however also said that it considers that any possible competition concerns, which might arise from the conduct of Nokia, following the transaction, in the licensing of the patent portfolio for smart mobile devices which it has retained falls outside the scope of the EU Merger Regulation.
The Commission said that it cannot take account of such concerns in the assessment of the current transaction. Indeed, Nokia is the seller whereas the Commission's investigation relates to the merged entity. However, the Commission said that it will remain vigilant and closely monitor Nokia's post-merger licensing practices under EU antitrust rules, in particular Article 102 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) that prohibits the abuse of a dominant market position.
The Commission considered that all the relevant markets affected by the transaction are at least EEA-wide, if not worldwide, in scope.