Preliminary Judgement Rejects Motorola's Patent Claims Against Aruba Networks

Aruba Networks has announced that the U.S. Patent & Trademark Office issued a preliminary re-examination report rejecting all claims of Patent No. 6,973,622, which was asserted against Aruba Networks by Motorola in 2007. In rejecting all of the patent's claims, and provided that the preliminary finding is made final, the USPTO's decision would invalidate the entire patent.

Motorola originally asserted four patents -- two from its Wireless Valley division and two from its Symbol Technologies division -- against Aruba with no advance notice immediately preceding Aruba's fiscal fourth quarter 2007 earnings conference call in August 2007. Aruba subsequently filed counterclaims and also requested that the Patent Office re-examine all four patents based, among other things, on substantial prior art unearthed by Aruba. The Patent Office agreed to do so, and today's preliminary report is a result of Aruba's re-examination request.

The three other re-examinations are still pending.

Requests for re-examination, like the ones filed by Aruba, are often successful in having the subject patent either changed or completely revoked. Motorola itself admitted in a court filing in 2008 that approximately 76% of patents subject to re-examination are either changed or cancelled. In this case, the Patent Office relied heavily on Wireless Valley's own User Manual, which predated its patent application by over twelve months and which Wireless Valley failed to provide in full to the Patent Office. The preliminary finding validates Aruba's challenge to this patent as invalid, and also provides support to Aruba's counterclaim of inequitable conduct by Wireless Valley in its prosecution of this patent.

"We believe that the existence of prior art, especially Wireless Valley's own User Manual, that predated Wireless Valley's patent filing carried great weight with the Patent Office," said Mike Reinemann of Cesari and McKenna, patent counsel to Aruba.

In September 2008 Aruba filed a patent infringement countersuit against Motorola, Symbol, and Wireless Valley. The countersuit alleges that Motorola (and its subsidiaries) infringe two of Aruba patents related to managing wireless computer networks and network security. The first asserted patent was assumed by Aruba as part of its acquisition of AirWave Wireless, while the second asserted patent was issued to Aruba in May 2008. Aruba is seeking a permanent injunction against use of its patented technologies, as well as monetary damages for infringing use.

Posted to the site on 11th February 2009